Thumbs down for Labour's planned tax increases

The respected and independent Institute for Fiscal Studies passed its judgment on the Labour Party manifesto. The tax rises are huge and not as innocuous as the impression given, notably in Labour’s greybook, with higher prices, lower wages and reduced investment expected to follow. Whatever the basic maths based on ready-reckoners, the behavioural changes could be huge – and not for the better.

But is this even possible? Head of the think tank, Paul Johnson, described the claim: 'It's impossible to understate just how extraordinary this manifesto is in terms of the sheer scale of money being spent and raised through the tax system. Take it from me, these are vast numbers, enormous, colossal. They suggest that all of that will come from companies and people earning over £80,000 a year. That is simply not credible.'

The IFS concluded on taxes:

Labour’s proposed income tax rise for those with incomes above £80,000 would affect only the highest-income 3% of adults. But this accounts for less than a tenth of the additional revenue Labour says it would raise.

About three-quarters of the revenue comes from increasing taxes on companies and their shareholders. It would be a mistake to think of this as falling entirely on ‘the rich’.

To the extent that corporation tax falls on company shareholders, that includes everyone with a defined contribution pension. And in practice much of the burden will be passed on to companies’ employees through lower wages, and customers through higher prices – and that means all of us.

Labour proposes to raise the main rate of corporation tax to 26% and reintroduce a small profits rate at 21%. In terms of headline tax rate, that would move the UK from one of the lowest headline rates in the OECD to above average. Alongside other corporation tax increases proposed, this would move the UK from raising an average share of national income in corporation tax to the highest in the G7 – if the reform raises the revenue Labour hopes.

In the short run, the increase in the rate of corporation tax might bring in the £20 billion Labour says. In the long run it would bring in less, as a less competitive rate would reduce investment, and therefore productivity and wages, in the UK.

Labour’s proposed reforms to the taxation of capital gains and dividends could represent moves in the right direction; its proposal for a financial transactions tax much less so.


Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Employment is rising in Wales

Image
Employment in Wales has been rising since 2012. It has risen from 1.32 million to 1.46 million in the last seven years. There has been no dip or change in trend due to the referendum. When will remainers see the facts and stop imaging a non-existent slowdown and crisis? People trying to stop Brexit normally focus on the economic damage that it will bring. Project Fear, inspired by the Treasury, predicted a fall in employment and a massive rise in unemployment. The reverse has happened. The rising trend does not mean that all is well in Wales - or elsewhere in the UK. The problems include: many of the new jobs might be low paid, part time, low skilled or zero hours contracts. Immigration is still rising and the new arrivers are more successful at getting the jobs. There will be many ups and downs in the years ahead but the Brexit downturn has not happened. Regional labour market data comes from the ONS .
Read more

Corbyn on Brexit - the leave vote utterly betrayed

Corbyn equivocation will mean that the Welsh vote to leave the EU will be dishonoured, disrespected and disregarded and utterly betrayed by Labour. "Brexit in name only" is the best you'll get from Labour - and that's not Brexit.  Jeremy Corbyn   appeared on   The Andrew Marr Show on Sunday 17 November. He was asked about both Labour’s and his personal position on Brexit.  Asked by Marr if he wants the UK to leave the EU or not, he said: "We're going to put that choice to the British people, and they will make that decision. We'll negotiate within three months a credible, sensible option of Leave, and put that alongside Remain in a referendum." Pressed about his own personal view, the Labour leader said: "I want a close relationship with the EU in the future. And we will put that decision to the British people, and I will abide by that decision. That's the view we've come to in the Labour Party… A Leave option would mean a tra
Read more

Universal Credit - The Brexit Party policy

We had two or three people in Neath today ask about The Brexit Party policy on Universal Credit. They seemed to be examples of the people who have lost out – due both to bad running of the system and iniquitous reworking of payments. So, for clarity this is what the “ Contract ” says: Providing a safety net for those in need is a defining mark of a civilised society. The Universal Credit system has not achieved what was intended and needs to be revisited. We pledge to:  • Support those who have paid into the system with accelerated payment processes (five-week maximum), and continue to root out fraud.  • Undertake a 12-month review of the system and bring in reforms within two years.  • Review the position of women unexpectedly short-changed by recent rises in the state pension age.  • Extend the use of dormant funds to support civil society. The review seems to be the most important part of the plan - the system has to be fair and trusted. 
Read more